The ethics of dog breeding: Balancing profit and welfare

by | Feb 15, 2024

Introduction

Breeding dogs is a complex endeavor that requires careful consideration of both ethical and practical factors. When it comes to breeding practices, opinions can vary widely. In this article, we’ll delve into the controversial topic of back-to-back breeding—a practice where a female dog (bitch) is mated again shortly after giving birth to a litter. Specifically, we’ll explore the case of Balihara Ranch kennel, where such practices have raised eyebrows and sparked debate.

Reasons for back-to-back breeding

  • Increasing the number of puppies from a female during her breeding life.
  • Shortening the interval between litters of puppies.
  • Increasing breeding productivity.

Disadvantages of back-to-back breeding

  • Increased physical and psychological demands on the female.
  • Increased risk of health complications for both the female and the puppies.
  • Reduction in the quality of puppies.

The Balihara Ranch Controversy

At Balihara Ranch, female dogs are mated just 2–3 months after their previous litter. This rapid turnaround raises several critical questions:

  • Health and Well-Being: The standard practice is for a dam to care for her puppies for approximately two months. But at Balihara Ranch, the turnaround is swift. How does this impact the health and well-being of the mother dog? Is she given enough time to recover physically and emotionally?
  • Profit vs. Welfare: Clearly, this approach treats dogs as mere commodities. The focus seems to be on maximizing profit rather than ensuring the welfare of the animals. But is this ethical? Shouldn’t responsible breeding prioritize the health and happiness of the dogs over financial gains?
  • Pedigree and Ethics: Balihara Ranch is not alone in its practices. However, the difference lies in the pedigree. While typical dog factories churn out puppies without regard for lineage, Balihara Ranch claims to breed pedigreed dogs. Does this make a difference? Or is it just a marketing ploy and the dogs at Balihara Ranch are treated the same as in a lowly puppy mill factory?

The Role of Relevant Clubs and the FCI

The Kennel Club and the Fédération Cynologique Internationale (FCI) play crucial roles in regulating dog breeding. They set standards, guidelines, and ethical norms. So how does Balihara Ranch’s approach align with these organizations’ principles?

  • Legal and Ethical Boundaries: Back-to-back mating is generally frowned upon by responsible breeders. Some countries even consider it illegal for licensed breeders. The health of the bitch and the well-being of the puppies take precedence.
  • Balihara Ranch Perspective: The owner of Balihara Ranch defends her practices. She argues that her dogs are well-cared-for and healthy. But is this enough? Shouldn’t ethical breeding go beyond physical health and consider emotional well-being?

The Dilemma: Profit vs. Ethics

Ultimately, the debate boils down to a fundamental question: Are dogs commodities or sentient beings? Responsible breeders recognize the emotional and physical toll that breeding takes on both the bitch and her offspring. They prioritize the long-term welfare of the animals over short-term gains.

Conclusion

As prospective dog owners, it’s essential to be informed. When choosing a breeder, consider not only the pedigree but also the breeder’s ethics. Responsible breeding involves respect for dogs, allowing them time to recover, and ensuring their well-being. So, let’s take a close look at the Number of days between litters at Balihara Ranch and reflect on the delicate balance between profit and compassion in the world of dog breeding.

Send a comment

* name and email address are optional, you can send the comment anonymously

CONTINUE READING

When Numbers Start Calling the Shots: The Economics Turning Breeding Into a Production Model (Part I)

by | Jan 8, 2026

When breeding is driven by numbers, its underlying logic shifts. Available data on Balihara Ranch indicate repeated use of the same sire–dam combinations, yielding dozens of puppies from the same pair. This article examines where responsible breeding selection ends and a production model begins—and why, without firm guardrails, the system naturally steers breeders toward volume over thoughtful selection.

read more

A New Year’s Wish – If Dogs Could Speak

by | Jan 1, 2026

As we enter the New Year, our wish is not for more, but for less. Fewer litters and fewer dogs where breeding has become an industry. Less silence around large commercial breeding operations. Because not everything that is legal is also right—and dogs have no way to say so out loud.

read more

The Cost of a Career Built on Dogs

by | Dec 18, 2025

When dog breeding becomes the primary source of income and identity, stepping back without losses becomes impossible. A large commercial breeding operation like Balihara Ranch requires constant escalation, the concealment of reality, and the defense of a system that can no longer be acknowledged as problematic. This is not an individual failure, but the logical outcome of a career built exclusively on dogs.

read more

The Qaiser van’t Stokerybos Case: Paper Exports as an Illusion of Oversight Part II: How a System Can Appear Lawful While Being Circumvented in Practice

by | Dec 11, 2025

The Qaiser van’t Stokerybos case shows how easily exports in dog breeding can be used not for cooperation between breeders, but to bypass the rules. A dog may be officially registered abroad while being physically used to breed females elsewhere—without the system addressing that contradiction.

read more