Legal Doesn’t Mean Right: When Laws Become an Alibi for Cruelty

by | Aug 14, 2025

At first glance, the kennel Balihara Ranch seems to tick all the boxes. The puppies are microchipped, vaccinated, registered in both national and international pedigree databases (FCI), and come with official papers. On paper, everything looks perfect.

But laws protect the bare minimum. And the bare minimum has never meant dignity—or ethics.

  • The law allows a female dog to be bred 7 or 8 times in her life.
  • The law doesn’t prohibit selling a puppy to a broker, with no knowledge of where the puppy ends up.
  • The law doesn’t address dogs kept in overcrowded runs with zero human bonding.

And that’s where legality and ethics part ways. The law ensures everything is in order on paper. Ethics demand a life of dignity for the dogs. That difference is not only vast—it’s painfully visible at Balihara Ranch.

From Puppy Buyers

Many buyers say the transaction seemed perfectly “legit.” The puppy had papers, a microchip, vaccinations—the whole package. But once home, reality hit: fearfulness, behavioral issues, and complete lack of socialization.

These stories prove one thing: legal compliance isn’t enough.
A dog is not a document or a stamp—it’s a sentient being.

Every buyer holds the power to change this system. Not by blindly trusting paperwork, but by asking the hard questions about how and where these puppies are raised.

Ethics Begin Where the Law Ends

So let’s ask: Can this really be called “breeding with love”?
Can we talk about responsibility when dogs are treated like inventory?

Balihara Ranch stands as proof that legal doesn’t mean right.
Just because something isn’t illegal, doesn’t mean it isn’t cruel.

And where animals are reduced to line items on a spreadsheet, we don’t need new laws—we need a conscience. Because when the law stays silent, our ethics shouldn’t.

That’s the difference between a breeder and a manufacturer.

So next time someone says, “But it’s all perfectly legal”, ask:
Is it also right?

Because if the law protects only the minimum, it’s up to us to protect the rest.
Dogs deserve more than just the legal bare minimum.

Share this:

Send a comment

* name and email address are optional, you can send the comment anonymously

CONTINUE READING

When the System Stops Protecting Dogs: The Blind Spots in the FCI System and Breed Clubs That Enable Extreme-Scale Breeding (Part II)

In the first part, we showed where the system fails in the field — in limits, inspections, and exports. This second part uncovers something even more serious: club-level exceptions, conflicts of interest, and lax oversight by the Slovak Cynological Union (SKJ), all of which have allowed kennels like Balihara Ranch to grow to a scale that today’s mechanisms can no longer effectively regulate.

read more

When the System Stops Protecting Dogs:The Blind Spots in the FCI System and Breed Clubs That Enable Extreme-Scale Breeding (Part I)

Current rules of the FCI and breed clubs contain fundamental blind spots: no limits on litters, no meaningful welfare inspections and weak oversight of exports. These gaps create the conditions in which extreme-scale kennels can thrive. And the only way to stop them is to change the system itself — not to address individual cases, such as the Balihara Ranch kennel, only after they grow beyond what today’s club and legislative mechanisms are capable of handling.

read more

When One Breeder Needs Two Breeding Advisors: An Unusual Decision of the Slovak Club of Swiss Mountain Dogs That Reveals More Than It First Appears

The Slovak Club of Swiss Mountain Dogs has published an exceptional detail: two breeding advisors assigned to the owner of the Balihara Ranch kennel — the only such case in the entire system. This rare exception signals that behind the polished façade of the kennel may conceal a far greater scale of breeding activity and administrative workload than the public typically imagines.

read more

When Facts Move Behind Closed Doors: How the Slovak Club of Swiss Mountain Dogs Locked Its Breeding Records After One Member’s Complaint

The Slovak Club of Swiss Mountain Dogs (SKSSP) has moved its breeding data behind closed doors after a complaint from the owner of Balihara Ranch Kennel. The data didn’t vanish — they were simply moved out of sight. Transparency has turned into a privilege, leaving honest breeders in the shadow of those who found facts inconvenient.

read more